Skip to main content

Editorial - The Guardian

 

 

 

Becoming the world’s most populous nation allows India to burnish its credentials as a global economic and political heavyweight. With a population that is much younger than those of China, the US and the EU, there will be renewed interest in India’s potential to be a beacon of liberal values. The west is eager to draw a democratic giant into its orbit. China and India will together account for about half of all global growth this year. But India risks emulating its bigger northern neighbour’s economic ascent under tight political control by a dominant authoritarian party.

Hindu nationalism in India is writing an epitaph for the country’s experiment with multi-ethnic secular democracy. Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata party (BJP) has weakened institutions meant to keep the state both transparent and accountable. Information is censored, civil society hounded and protests suppressed. It is absurd that opposition leaders have been targeted to the extent that Mr Modi’s main rival – Rahul Gandhi – is currently disqualified from parliament. Such is the polarisation in politics that India’s last parliamentary session was the least productive since 1952.

Mr Modi’s party has bent state institutions to service its ideology. This has effectively rendered minorities second-class citizens. The suppression of the civil rights of the world’s largest minority group, about 200 million Muslims, is unlikely to be viable over a long period without giving up on democracy. This would be a terrible outcome for India and the world.

Most western countries only enfranchised all voters after industrialising. India had been an exception to the rule that capitalism comes before democracy. Its citizens acquired the right to vote well before modern industrial development. Autocrats have long claimed that democracy was inefficient. That argument entrenches at best “enlightened despotism”, but more often just brutal dictatorship. Deng Xiaoping told foreign observers in 1987 that democracy on the mainland might be viable in “half a century”. That prediction – of Chinese elections by 2037 – looks unlikely to be fulfilled.

Until 1990, India’s per capita income was higher than that of China; now it is only about a fifth of China’s. Beijing’s success was to integrate into the world economy without losing control of its domestic one. This was more about economics than politics. Mr Modi’s bet is that a single Hindu identity can transcend Indian society’s faultlines of religion, caste, region and language. Yet his parliamentary majority rests on the votes of just a quarter of the electorate. Large parts of India, especially its more developed regions, are resistant to his polarising politics. His crackdown on dissent is about weakness, not strength.

India’s democratic reversal is also rooted in a development model that suits global concerns rather than domestic ones. Because of its economic heft, India is a member of the G20. Its citizens, however, are the poorest in this group. The richest 5% of Indians can consume the same goods as the average Briton. Therefore the outside world tends to be interested in Indian success as defined by the growth in this class – as the greater their purchasing power is, the larger the market for global goods and services.

The latest Lamborghini sports car models, which cost £400,000, are already sold out in India. But 350m Indians went hungry in 2022, up from 190m in 2018. Rather than taxing the rich and corporates to fund health and education, the BJP has taxed the poor to pay for public services. India added zero net new jobs over the past decade, even as the number of people in the labour force rose by more than 100 million. The country’s democratic rise is far from assured. But for it to be sustained, there must be a political consensus that the prosperity of all its people, not just those at the top, should be increased.

… as 2023 gathers pace, and you’re joining us from Bahrain, we have a small favour to ask. A new year means new opportunities, and we're hoping this year gives rise to some much-needed stability and progress. Whatever happens, the Guardian will be there, providing clarity and fearless, independent reporting from around the world, 24/7.

Times are tough, and we know not everyone is in a position to pay for news. But as we’re reader-funded, we rely on the ongoing generosity of those who can afford it. This vital support means millions can continue to read reliable reporting on the events shaping our world. Will you invest in the Guardian this year?

Unlike many others, we have no billionaire owner, meaning we can fearlessly chase the truth and report it with integrity. 2023 will be no different; we will work with trademark determination and passion to bring you journalism that’s always free from commercial or political interference. No one edits our editor or diverts our attention from what’s most important. 

With your support, we’ll continue to keep Guardian journalism open and free for everyone to read. When access to information is made equal, greater numbers of people can understand global events and their impact on people and communities. Together, we can demand better from the powerful and fight for democracy.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Bhagawan Dasante Ramarajyam: A Mirror to Society

"Bhagawan Dasante Ramarajyam" is not just a satire; it's a powerful reflection of the reality we live in. The movie dares to strip away the veils of hypocrisy, much like how the 'rakshasas' in the story unpant Lord Rama—not out of respect, but to display their ego, hatred, and defiance against what is righteous and just.  This film holds up a true mirror to a country grappling with polarization, where media and politicians often seem biased and divisive. Amidst this chaos, it's not the powerful but the common people, activists, books, and films like this that fight to preserve democracy and protect the essence of humanity. "Bhagawan Dasante Ramarajyam" speaks boldly to this struggle, presenting an intense and thought-provoking narrative. Its theme, while allegorical, is a canvas for the harsh truths of society, urging viewers to reflect on the very state of our democratic values and social harmony. The film stands as a beacon of resistance, reminding...

Declining of social values

 Our society once said to be the essence of culture, morality, and character, is today continuously degenerating and deteriorating in terms of ethics, morals and values. The influences of mass media, science and technology, modernization, globalization etc. are the prime factors for the degeneration of the youth in our society and corrupting the mind of a large number of youngsters. The youngsters are busy preparing for their careers and enjoying their life. They have little concern for social problems or family affairs. The old people are often neglected. Electronic gadgets and mobile apps have changed the methods of learning. Children are addicted to the online mode of education. As the effect of the pandemic is diminishing, they have started attending offline classes. But we see nowadays that they have less regard for their mentors and they are glued to their ipads and laptops. So social values are deteriorating because of multiple reasons, one is the engagement of people....

Society with shared values

 Creating a society that is both moral and progressive while preserving human values requires a balanced approach that fosters ethical behavior, inclusivity, and innovation. At its core, such a society emphasizes education that fosters not only knowledge but also ethics, empathy, and social responsibility. Ethical leadership is crucial, with leaders who demonstrate integrity and prioritize the common good. Strengthening community bonds and encouraging inclusivity are vital for building trust and ensuring that progress benefits all members of society. Respect for human dignity and rights forms the foundation, guiding actions and policies that uphold justice and fight against discrimination.  A harmonious blend of tradition and innovation allows for growth without losing touch with cultural heritage. Environmental stewardship ensures that progress does not come at the expense of future generations. Open dialogue, tolerance, and support for mental well-being further enrich the so...